J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2020 (Sep); 43 (7): 667–674 ~ FULL TEXT
James M. Whedon, DC, MS, Andrew W.J. Toler, MS, Serena Bezdjian, PhD, Robb Russell, DC, Louis A. Kazal, MD, Melissa Nagare, DC, LAc
Health Services Research,
Southern California University Health System,
Southern California University of Health Sciences,
Objective: The objective of this investigation was to compare the value of primary spine care (PSC) with usual care for management of patients with spine-related disorders (SRDs) within a primary care setting.
Methods: We retrospectively examined existing patient encounter data at 3 primary care sites within a multi-clinic health system. Designated clinicians serve in the role as PSC as the initial point of contact for spine patients, coordinate, and follow up for the duration of the episode of care. A PSC may be a chiropractor, physical therapist, or medical or osteopathic physician who has been trained to provide primary care for patients with SRDs. The PSC model of care had been introduced at site I (Lebanon, New Hampshire); sites II (Bedford, New Hampshire) and III (Nashua, New Hampshire) served as control sites where patients received usual care. To evaluate cost outcomes, we employed a controlled quasi-experimental design for analysis of health claims data. For analysis of clinical outcomes, we compared clinical records for PSC at site I and usual care at sites II and III, all with reference to usual care at site I. We examined clinical encounters occurring over a 24-month period, from February 1, 2016 through January 31, 2018.
Results: Primary spine care was associated with reduced total expenditures compared with usual care for SRDs. At site I, average per-patient expenditure was $162 in year 1 and $186 in year 2, compared with site II ($332 in year 1; $306 in year 2) and site III ($467 in year 1; $323 in year 2).
Conclusion: Among patients with spine-related disorders (SRDs) included in this study, implementation of the primary spine care (PSC) model within a conventional primary care setting was associated with a trend toward reduced total expenditures for spine care compared with usual primary care. Implementation of PSC may lead to reduced costs and resource utilization, but may be no more effective than usual care regarding clinical outcomes.
Keywords: Back Pain; Chiropractic; Low Back Pain; Neck Pain; Primary Health Care.
A systematic review of clinical pathways for lower back pain
and introduction of the Saskatchewan Spine Pathway.
Spine (Phila Pa). 2011; 36: S164-S171
Murphy DR, Justice BD, Paskowski IC, Perle SM, Schneider MJ.
The Establishment of a Primary Spine Care Practitioner
and Its Benefits To Health Care Reform in the United States
Chiropractic & Manual Therapies 2011 (Jul 21); 19 (1): 17
The Rationale for Primary Spine Care Employing Biopsychosocial, Stratified
and Diagnosis-based Care-pathways at a Chiropractic College Public Clinic:
A Literature Review
Chiropractic & Manual Therapies 2013 (Jun 9); 21 (1): 19
Primary Spine Care Services: Responding to Runaway Costs
and Disappointing Outcomes in Spine Care
Rhode Island Medical Journal 2014 (Oct 1); 97 (10): 47–49
Goertz, CM, Weeks, WB, Justice, B, and Haldeman, S.
A Proposal to Improve Health-care Value in Spine Care Delivery:
The Primary Spine Practitioner
Spine J. 2017 (Oct); 17 (10): 1570–1574
Qaseem A, Wilt TJ, McLean RM, Forciea MA;
Noninvasive Treatments for Acute, Subacute, and Chronic Low Back Pain:
A Clinical Practice Guideline From the American College of Physicians
Annals of Internal Medicine 2017 (Apr 4); 166 (7): 514–530
Clinical Reasoning in Spine Pain. Volume I: Primary Management
of Low Back Disorders Using the CRISP Protocols (Volume 1).
awtucket, RI: CRISP; 2013.
Clinical Reasoning in Spine Pain. Volume II: Primary Management
of Cervical Disorders Using the CRISP Protocols (Volume 1).
Pawtucket, RI: CRISP; 2016.
Relationship between categorization with the STarT Back Screening Tool
and prognosis for people receiving physical therapy for low back pain.
Phys Ther. 2011; 91: 722-732
Exploring the cost-utility of stratified primary care management for
low back pain compared with current best practice within risk-defined subgroups.
Ann Rheum Dis. 2012; 71: 1796-1802
Effect of stratified care for low back pain in family practice (IMPaCT Back):
a prospective population-based sequential comparison.
Ann Fam Med. 2014; 12: 102-111
Johnson CD, Haldeman S, Chou R, Nordin M, Green BN, Côté P, Hurwitz EL et al (2018)
The Global Spine Care Initiative: Model of Care and Implementation
European Spine Journal 2018 (Sep); 27 (Suppl 6): 925–945
The effectiveness of a stratified group intervention using the STarTBack
screening tool in patients with LBP - a non randomised controlled trial.
BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2013; 14: 342
Weeks WB, Pike J, Donath J, Fiacco P, Justice BD.
Conservative Spine Care Pathway Implementation is Associated with Reduced
Health Care Expenditures in a Controlled, Before-After Observational Study
J General Internal Medicine 2019 (Aug); 34 (8): 1381–1382
ACR–ASSR–SPR–SSR Practice parameter for the performance of spine radiography.
Accessed May 1, 2020.
American Chiropractic Association.
Avoid routine spinal imaging in the absence of clear clinical indicators
for patients with acute low back pain of less than six (6) weeks duration.
Accessed June 24, 2020.
Horn ME, George SZ, Fritz JM.
Influence of Initial Provider on Health Care Utilization
in Patients Seeking Care for Neck Pain
Mayo Clin Proc Innov Qual Outcomes. 2017 (Oct 19); 1 (3): 226–233
Lisi AJ, Corcoran KL, DeRycke EC, et al.
Opioid Use Among Veterans of Recent Wars Receiving
Veterans Affairs Chiropractic Care
Pain Med. 2018 (Sep 1); 19 (suppl_1): S54–S60
James M. Whedon, DC, MS, Andrew W.J. Toler, MS, Justin M. Goehl, DC, MS, and Louis A. Kazal, MD
Association Between Utilization of Chiropractic Services for
Treatment of Low-Back Pain and Use of Prescription Opioids
J Altern Complement Med. 2018 (Jun); 24 (6): 552–556
Corcoran KL, Bastian LA, Gunderson CG, Steffens C, Brackett A, Lisi AJ
Association Between Chiropractic Use and Opioid Receipt Among
Patients with Spinal Pain: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
Pain Medicine 2020 (Feb 1); 21 (2): e139–e145
Kazis LE, Ameli O, Rothendler J, et al.
Observational Retrospective Study of the Association of Initial Healthcare Provider
for New-onset Low Back Pain with Early and Long-term Opioid Use
BMJ Open. 2019 (Sep 20); 9 (9): e028633
Return to LOW BACK PAIN
Return to CHRONIC NECK PAIN
Return to COST-EFFECTIVENESS
Return to INTEGRATED HEALTH CARE
Return to SPINAL PAIN MANAGEMENT