Table 2

Characteristics of included studies by reporting on AEs

Overall (n=154), n (%)Reports on AE (n=94), n (%)Does not report on AE
(n=60), n (%)
ICMJE journal
 Published in ICJME journal53 (34.4)33 (35.1)20 (33.3)

Risk of bias
 Low risk13 (8.4)10 (10.6)3 (5.0)
 Some concerns47 (30.5)29 (30.9)18 (30.0)
 High risk94 (61.0)55 (58.5)39 (65.0)

Impact factor
 Upper tertile47 (30.5)36 (38.3)11 (18.3)
 Middle tertile54 (35.1)37 (39.4)17 (28.3)
 Lower tertile53 (34.4)21 (22.3)32 (53.3)

Spinal region
 Cervical24 (15.6)17 (18.1)7 (11.7)
 Thoracic33 (21.4)15 (16.0)18 (30.0)
 Lumbopelvic28 (18.2)13 (13.8)15 (25.0)
 Mixed/unclear69 (44.8)49 (52.1)20 (33.3)

Type of practitioner
 Chiropractor36 (23.4)29 (30.9)7 (11.7)
 Osteopath15 (9.7)6 (6.4)9 (15.0)
 Physiotherapist63 (40.9)35 (37.2)28 (46.7)
 Medical practitioner9 (5.8)4 (4.3)5 (8.3)
 Mixed/other/unclear31 (20.1)20 (21.2)11 (18.3)

Sample size spinal manipulation group*
 Upper tertile51 (33.3)40 (42.6)11 (18.6)
 Middle tertile50 (32.7)28 (29.8)22 (37.3)
 Lower tertile52 (34.0)26 (27.7)26 (44.1)

*One study with unclear sample size excluded.

AE, adverse event;