BMJ Open 2024 (Nov 19); 14 (11): e083509

Table 2. Total, natural direct and natural indirect effects occurring through pain interference and pain intensity of chiropractic care on physical function, fatigue, sleep disturbance and social roles.

Model outcome Effect Estimate SE 95% CI P value
Physical function TNDE −0.54 0.59 −1.60 to 0.72 0.494
TNIE −1.66 0.34 −2.23 to −0.96 <0.001
Total effect −2.21 0.62 −3.13 to −0.77 <0.001
Proportion mediated 0.77 3.68 0.43 to 2.00 0.006

Fatigue TNDE −1.01 0.80 −2.73 to 0.43 0.158
TNIE −1.62 0.39 −2.37 to −0.85 <0.001
Total effect −2.63 0.82 −4.29 to −1.05 0.004
Proportion mediated 0.62 1.09 0.30 to 1.65 0.002

Sleep disturbance TNDE −1.15 0.67 −2.13 to 0.45 0.204
TNIE −1.11 0.29 −1.90 to −0.74 <0.001
Total effect −2.26 0.66 −3.36 to −0.87 0.006
Proportion mediated 0.49 3.42 0.31 to 1.49 0.008

Social roles TNDE −0.49 0.73 −1.88 to 0.96 0.548
TNIE −1.94 0.43 −2.97 to −1.32 <0.001
Total effect −2.43 0.78 −4.06 to −1.12 <0.001
Proportion mediated 0.81 0.71 0.50 to 1.97 0.004

Physical function and social roles are transformed to make a higher score a worse outcome, consistent with other PROMIS-29 measures. A negative effect estimate favours the usual medical care plus chiropractic care treatment arm over the usual medical care alone arm.

PROMIS = Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System
TNDE = total natural direct effect;
TNIE = total natural indirect effect