Logo of jchiromedGuide for AuthorsAbout this journalExplore this journalJournal of Chiropractic Medicine

Table 5

Summary of included commentaries, letters to editors, cross-sectional surveys, and protocols

ReferencesPeer reviewedYearType of articleConclusion of SMT for OMComments
Steele et al45Yes2010ProtocolAn osteopathic manipulative medicine protocol can be administered to pediatrics with no serious adverse events.Final outcomes from this trial should be out in late 2010.
Alcantara et al46Yes2010Cross-sectional survey15.6% responding DCs stated that ear, nose, and throat (ie, OM) conditions motivated a child's presentation to their office.A total of 548/1550 members of the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association completed the survey.
Pohlman et al47Yes2010Cross-sectional surveyEar infections were reported with an average treatment frequency of 1 to 3 visits per month.135/218 doctors of chiropractic with a diplomate in pediatrics completed this survey.
Hewitt et al48Yes2008CommentaryA short course of chiropractic care may have a good effect to chronic OM.This article included a description of CAM therapies that could be used in conjunction with SMT, a possible SMT mechanism of action, and a typical course of SMT care for OM.
Galgano49Yes2007Letter to the editorNo conclusion.Critique of “Reducing recurrent otitis media with OMT” by Degenhardt et al
Orenstein50Yes2007Letter to the editorOMT's impact on recurrent AOM needs an appropriately structured clinical trial; not enough information at this time to conclude.Critique of “Reducing recurrent otitis media with OMT” by Degenhardt et al
Fallon51Yes2004CommentaryRemoval of a subluxation, regardless of technique, could have impact on OM; a child with this condition should have his or her upper cervical area examined carefully.The audio tract lectured about the guidelines for OM, recent research of SMT on OM, the pathophysiology of OM, examination procedures, physiology of the subluxation components, and appropriate adjustments.
Killinger52Yes2004CommentaryFallon demonstrated a compelling argument for SMT on OM, but further investigation on this topic is necessary.Critique of “The role of chiropractic adjustment in the care and treatment of 332 children with OM” by Fallon.
Pichichero53Yes2003Letter to the editorConclusions of the OMT for OM could not be drawn from the critiqued article.Critique of “The use of osteopathic manipulative treatment as adjuvant therapy in children with recurrent acute otitis media” by Mills et al
No named author54Yes2002CommentaryDid not state any conclusion.Discussed the etiology for OM and standard treatment options. The article then discussed Fallon's case series and had some material and quotes from Fallon.
Warner55Yes2000CommentarySMT may reduce tight neck muscles, which could improve fluid drainage.Gave quotes regarding research findings on antibiotics for OM and suggested that DCs communicate these with their patients.
Lamm and Ginter56Yes1998CommentaryThere are a number of interventions, including SMT, within the chiropractic scope of care, which can be done, with close monitoring, during an acute episode.This article discussed epidemiology of OM, evaluation strategies, and possible management options. It also discussed a formal process that the Western States Chiropractic College clinical standards, protocols, and education committee used to gather and appraise available literature on this subject.
Bowers57Yes1997CommentaryStated that there are no current recommendations for SMT use on OM.This article reviewed pediatric conditions and current practice guidelines.
DiGiorgi58Yes1997CommentaryCotreatment of pediatric OM between a pediatrician and a chiropractor is a valid option.Described the different types of OM, anatomy of the ear, standards of care for OM, and how chiropractic care may affect OM.
Vallone and Fallon59Yes1997Cross-sectional survey24 different modalities were potentially used as a treatment by DCs for OM. Unanimous agreement for use of chiropractic adjustment of the atlas and the occiput, as well as removal of dairy/wheat from diet and manual lymphatic drainage.Survey explored the management protocols of children with OM and asthma by 33 DCs enrolled into a postgraduate pediatric program.
Whiteside60No1993CommentaryExperimentally, physiotherapist claims success with manipulation to cervical spine and massage of neck and shoulders.Discussed cause for glue ear and potential management plans including CAM modalities.
Hendricks and Larkin-Thier61Yes1989CommentaryProper alignment of the spine may return normal function of eustachian tube, but clinical trials are needed to verify this conclusion.Reviewed anatomy of the ear, pathophysiology of OM, conventional care for OM.
AOM, Acute otitis media; CAM, complementary and alternative medicine; DC, doctor of chiropractic; OM, otitis media; OMT, osteopathic manipulative therapy; RCT, randomized clinical trial; SMT, spinal manipulation therapy.